Agrammaticality

Nuno Venturinha

pp. 159-175

in: Gisela Bengtsson, Simo Säätelä, Alois Pichler (eds), New essays on Frege, Berlin, Springer, 2018

Abstract

In this paper I begin by scrutinizing classic approaches to the question of agrammaticality, with a particular focus on Frege and the early Wittgenstein, and try to show that a further step is needed in order to adequately address this topic. I then focus on the later Wittgenstein's treatment of nonsense-poems and claim that the failure of the Philosophical Investigations as a book is actually connected with Wittgenstein's recognition that philosophy should be written under the form of poetry. The therapeutic consequences of this view are discussed in connection with Deleuze's comments on Melville and with Read's comments on Sass, which offer very different views of agrammaticality.

Cited authors

Frege Gottlob

Deleuze Gilles

Wittgenstein Ludwig